Home › Forums › Nitro for Mac › Lens correction › Reply To: Lens correction
I agree as well as I have some concerns based on my experiences with DxO 6 years ago. DxO claimed to have the best lens profiles, hand-knitted and specifically designed for certain lens/camera combinations. That was the reason for several problems: DxO confused one lens with another because the manufacturers, especially within the L-Mount Alliance, simply have no valid, open standard for the use of EXIF-data. Also, Sigma and Lumix (I believe, Leica as well) use different specifications in metadata for the same lens – I counted up to 7 different entries for the same 500/5.6 lens.
The same? No. The Nikkor 500/5.6 PF always had the same entry, although mounted to 2 different Nikon bodies. The Sigma 500/5.6 Sports was on 5 bodies and had 6 entries in the overview of lenses. Here it was the use of one of two teleconverters altering the lens’ name but this doesn’t explain a difference of 53 images between the count of EXIF lens entries (2106 in total) and body entries for the same lens (2159). Maybe Capture One is also messing up the data a bit, I used it’s filter functions.
Because we see the name of the lens in the metadata of the image, we tend to believe there’s some kind of standard, right? No. There are as many standards as lens- and body manufacturers and I don’t blame any software programmer for errors in the app caused by the manufacturer chaos.
And then there’s firmware and hardware updates: the same lens mounted on the same body can get 2 different entries after the body or the lens got a firmware update. All of a sudden the model name was altered as manufacturers are too stubborn to express the aperture values as they are meant: f/16 is not F16 or f-16, and it’s rather point- and clueless to describe a lens as i.e. Zeiss Planar 1.4/85. Dividing 1.4 by 85 = 01.01647… stubborn stupidity! 85 mm ÷ 1.4 = 60.714 mm and that’s the diameter of the diaphragm called aperture @ f/1.4. Longer focal lengths factor the same aperture number as a bigger diameter, shorter as a smaller. Planar 85 mm/1.4 would be the correct terminus. Apparently every marketing department sees this numbers as their playground, add some other characters and a chunk of glass, plastic and metal suddenly looks worth the price.
Sorry for the rant.
If manufacturers cannot agree on a naming pattern of the two most important values of a lens, imagine the confusion between owners and contributors of a project.
Now, if manufacturers already avoid an agreement about the use of metadata, how will the various members of the project deal with the problem? In repeatably the same way for each lens? Even the ones which don’t have their metadata onboard?
-
This reply was modified 3 weeks, 1 day ago by
JoJu.
